Sounds more like a M-LW to me.

I'll vote H-LW as well. His strongest offense are his weapons, and he isn't nearly as skilled as other H-Lw's, but he makes up for it by being super tough.

I can't remember what I voted for Bogby but I know I didn't put in a vote for Boy Blue, so put me down for 1 H-MW for him.

Hm, right now the only vote we have for Boy Blue is him with all his special (and extremely powerful) gear...

yeah, I'm voteing him H-MW with that.

That's quite a large drop from the L-SHW he was listed at

Yeah he's rated much too high in my opinion. Amuseingly however is that I think he's perform at that level almost as well, if not better, than against H-MW's. Fable's is more down to Earth than mainstream comics so even the most skilled an experienced fighter isn't a match for unenhanced combat masters from Marvel and DC, someone with high combat skills and superhuman agility would be a huge threat to him. By contrast a lot of SHW's are slow and bad fighters, that he would just chop up.

Compare him to Katana (who's rated like M or L MW), same sword, she's actually a better fighter (I can't see Blue parrying bullets), but then he has extra tricks so gets rated slightly higher. He certainly shouldn't be above Persuader who has got almost every ability he does (and then some), plus supertoughness, and several murdered planets to his name.

Makes sense, I buy that.

A lot of 'X anything' characters can be misplaced and do ok.

Did anyone read the Feedback comic from Who Wants to Be A Superhero? How would he rate?

I'm also going to put Shannon, as in one of Spider's filthy assistants from Transmet, as a L-LW.

Oooh, I just thought of a major book/group of books we've been overlooking. Alan Moore's ABC comic lines.

Smax(Top Ten) L-SHW
Rexa (Top Ten) L-SHW
Toybox (Top Ten)- Lightweight. Low? Mid? Opinions desired, she's only a human with little robots, some with guns, but multiple flying semi-autonomous weapons are fairly useful.
Girl One (Top Ten)- M-MW
The Commissioner (Top Ten)- H-SHW (she was supposed to be able to wipe a city full of science heroes off the map)



Tom Strong (Tom Strong)- H-LW
Telsa Strong (Tom Strong)- L-LW
Weird Rider (Tom Strong)- M-LW
The Modular Man (Tom Strong)- individual component, sub-LW, final version, S-SHW

dunno any of those, here are some from Bone that I had on the old list:

Rose Ben: H-LW
Fone Bone: L-LW
The Hooded One: H-Mw
The Great Red Dragon: L-Hw

I wish I could place more people from Fables, but they are mostly light weights and people I have a hard time classifying.

http://www.comicsbulletin.com/rage/i...koolaidman.jpg


Kool-aid man is a Sigil bearer, and apparently quite a powerful one.

Ok, here's one I'd be amazed if a lot of people haven't read: The League of Extrodinary Gentlemen.

Opinions?