I am thinking of trying to trade my Dark Phoenix away.
How much do you think a fair trade (monetarily so I can make it easy) for one without the box would be?
I was thinking roughly $25 would this be fair?

Looking at E-Bay for recent completed sales listings, I see the following:

7 listings. 4 SOLD.

$61.00
$66.00
$40.00
$55.00

Total = $222.00/4 = $55.50 average selling price.

All 4 that sold had the box.

I guess it depends on the person interested in it, if they care about the box or not. Do you have the original rules sheet to go with it, as that is another consideration for potential traders?

I'd say that $25.00 is 'fair', maybe even in their favor.

Yeah, I do have the original rules, but when we moved I believe my mother in law disposed of a lot of my boxes I had stored in the closet (thinking she was being helpful).

I just want to make sure if I am offering someone something like this for trade, they are not insulted. I don't want to have a reputation of a low baller.
Thanks for the help though

Cool. Well depending on what you are looking for, I might be interested in her

OK Man once I find out what the heck I need I'll get in contact with you
Thanks for the help!

You are more than welcome