You are currently viewing HCRealms.com, The Premier HeroClix Community, as a Guest. If you would like to participate in the community, please Register to join the discussion!
If you are having problems registering to an account, feel free to Contact Us.
I will say that giving the town a theme hurts the mafia. Coming up with role claims can often be challenging enough. Having to have them fit a theme that you don't know what it is adds to that.
Personally, I think the mafia should have been told the theme off the bat (as they usually know their own theme). But maybe I'm based here.
I thought it would have been pretty obvious after the first Townie (or two) died, coupled with me dying N0 as Carrie Matheson. *shrug*. Likely won't do it again, though.
The point of the Day Job power was to help with the fakeclaims, obviously, as there are tons of cop shows (Mentalist has the hot redhead, Criminal Minds has a hacker)
"Why would the possibility of me being wrong ever stop me from doing something?"
I thought it would have been pretty obvious after the first Townie (or two) died, coupled with me dying N0 as Carrie Matheson. *shrug*. Likely won't do it again, though.
The point of the Day Job power was to help with the fakeclaims, obviously, as there are tons of cop shows (Mentalist has the hot redhead, Criminal Minds has a hacker)
I thought it was a clever twist on mafia theme, so I liked it. Also notice that I picked up on the fact and was dismissed by the majority of the town.
I will say that giving the town a theme hurts the mafia. Coming up with role claims can often be challenging enough. Having to have them fit a theme that you don't know what it is adds to that.
Personally, I think the mafia should have been told the theme off the bat (as they usually know their own theme). But maybe I'm based here.
I figured out the town theme rather quick.
Fun game not sure how we ended up
With the hard on for IR, or why he kept targeting us.
Immortal raven, what have you got against me. Kill me night 1 in my first game back and when it doesn't work, off me again later. Seriously.
I blame random.org for the first one. Then I was pissed that you didn't die so I waited a couple nights and finished the job later. Nothing personal, all my targets as SK for N1 are randomized.
Quote : Originally Posted by gfishfunk
I am fairly smug on my Immortal_Raven read. He usually picks mafia with great acuity when he is the serial killer.
I do, but my read was off in the case of Fredwood. I was trying to take out townies. Incidentally, had you doubled me, I would have made you kill yourself.
Quote : Originally Posted by Magnito
Made me angrier when darq told me post mortum that he was mafia friendly. He kept killing us when he could have won with us.
Grumble.
The only intentional scummer kill was you Mags. I honestly thought Fredwood was town and wouldn't garner any protections, so I killed him. I did kind of know I could win with you, but wasn't 100% sure. The night I killed Rorschach, he was busdriven with spworld, my intended target. So yeah, only you, and pretty much only because you didn't die the first time.
I was shocked to make it as long as I did quite honestly. I was Dexter in gfish's "what If" game and once people saw Hannah here, I figured I was screwed.
Ah well, congrats to the winners. chaz got doctored on night 3, I tried to kill him too in addition to helping double-tap MSU for a post that I thought he was on to me with.
Truthfully, I knew Hannah was here from the night one poison kill. I just didn't want to say anything because well, I'd probably would have been the night 2 victim if I did.
Funny thing, she was one of my choices (so the poison kill stuck out like a sore thumb), but I removed her at the end to have another choice (whom wasn't in the game so I may go back to that well next HAWTness).
If you let them kill your dreams, it'll haunt you.
Make your own Change. Find an Office to run for in your local community.
Overall, I was happy with my targets. (Even if the results were skewed against me) Outside of JRS4, I think I picked all mafia aligned or mafia-friendly players.
If you let them kill your dreams, it'll haunt you.
Make your own Change. Find an Office to run for in your local community.
You had really good targets - the night you were doubled and got both Mafia, I thought the game was over
And then gFish up and lies about the results he got. As a mod, I was quite happy, because the Neutral role worked out exactly as I hoped - even better, really.
"Why would the possibility of me being wrong ever stop me from doing something?"
On a personal note, I was tempted to send him after the same person just to see what would happen. I was under the suspicion that some neutrals could be recruited by the mafia for quite a bit of the game. Quebbster's initial town result felt off to me, but I didn't address it until later (almost too late honestly).
If you let them kill your dreams, it'll haunt you.
Make your own Change. Find an Office to run for in your local community.
Though to be honest, it probably kept me alive as well. IR had no reason to kill me as I would get a town result on him, Magnito had a town result and Quebbster had a neutral shielding him. I kept wondering why I was still alive for so long, so I figured the mafia had a way to give me false negatives.
If you let them kill your dreams, it'll haunt you.
Make your own Change. Find an Office to run for in your local community.
Oh, and I always like to give props to Doctors who succeed, so congrats to Girathon for saving Charlesx. If you see the Night 3 writeup, you can pretty much tell that the two know eachother (hug when they leave), so that was kinda nice to include - even if it wasn't the way I would usually include a Doctoring.
"Why would the possibility of me being wrong ever stop me from doing something?"
Oh, and I always like to give props to Doctors who succeed, so congrats to Girathon for saving Charlesx. If you see the Night 3 writeup, you can pretty much tell that the two know eachother (hug when they leave), so that was kinda nice to include - even if it wasn't the way I would usually include a Doctoring.
Thank you. About half the nights I self doctored as I was really unsure this game. I felt safe with chaz though and thought he was going to draw some fire that night. The RB kill got me though.