RENUYU: Shape Change. When Clayface uses it and succeeds, give him a Renuyu token. Whenever Clayface rolls a single d6 for a power he's using, after rolling you may remove any number of Renuyu tokens to increase the result +1 for each token removed.

I posted this on the WIN, but I'd love y'alls thoughts here. Say I have 2 Renuyu tokens. I roll for shape change with Clayface and I roll a 3. I then remove both Renuyu tokens to make my roll a '5.' Since I now succeeded the shape change roll, do I now get to add a Renuyu token to Clayface?

That’s how I’ve interpreted it. You just got to get lucky and nail that first one.

Yeah, getting the first ones are the hard part.
After you have 1, it's effectively a SC on a 4- 6 with no deficit for that reason.
So far when using him, I've gotten to the giant reach per twice but I've never had more than GR:1 (which is really only helpful in corner cases)... but that's my luck with SC rolls. Lol!