While I could argue this character is so niche that they probably forgot him, I'll admit you have met my standard. This is a character that adds to the result instead of altering the subtraction, is Modern, and is unchanged. I don't really have anything left to defend my position at this time.

I think you have the wrong idea here.

See, this is the rules forum. This is where people come to ask questions about how the rules work and folks like LJ do their level best to answer. We're not saying that the "halve after tokens" interpretation is unreasonable. Hell, we're not even saying you can't play it that way, if you like. We're saying that, based on the rules as they exist today, that the power simply does not work that way.

We're not making moral judgements here, we're not expressing opinions, we're not scolding or browbeating anyone. We're simply interpreting the rules as written. That's what this forum is for.

That's fair. You're right that this is not the place to discuss this, and I kinda forgot that.

With that said, the reason why I used the word "unreasonable", was because LJ used it:I'll drop the discussion now, and I'll probably close this thread sometime tomorrow.

The funny thing is if you play the Hulk's Regeneration as d6 roll and tokens/2 you get to strategize a little more. Example: roll the d6 and say you roll a 5 and have 3 Anger tokens you would add only 2 tokens since the total result of 7/2 would be 4 (rounded up) because an 8/2 would be a 4 as well, so why waste the extra token.

Just something to think about.

Do you have to declare how many anger tokens you're adding before the roll or after?

Oh, back on topic. Great!

I'm not sure about the timing actually. It certainly has to be before the reroll-window closes, since the text "can't be rerolled" would otherwise be pointless, so it's definitely before the roll would otherwise be finalized. I think it happens before the d6 roll, as soon as you declare the use of Regeneration.

That's the way I read it too.

It's before the roll.

That is correct.