So you start on click 1, push this guy to hit a mystic, take two clicks of damage, then go back to click 1 at the end of your turn? Is the timing of that right? Thanks

That is absolutely correct.

Give him Masters of Evil TA for even more fun.

Not exactly. You HAVE to turn him to another click at the beginning of the turn if you want to click him back after. So, you turn him to another click, then push to hit mystics, then turn back to click 1.

Should've had close combat expert and sharpshooter