You are currently viewing HCRealms.com, The Premier HeroClix Community, as a Guest. If you would like to participate in the community, please Register to join the discussion!
If you are having problems registering to an account, feel free to Contact Us.
I'm dealing with a poorly-aging work computer that is prone to program slow-downs and crashes - especially browsers - which is part of the reason I have been dodging in and out mostly in silence today.
Unless someone's solidly locked in to wanting the characters be as they are in the comics, or simply walked into the wrong theater and wanted to see a different sort of movie -- or maybe if all the person heard in advance was glowing, hyperbolic praise -- I don't know what would lead someone to have a bad time with X-Men: First Class.
My thinking is that if the life span of a comic title/individual character/group of characters gets past a certain point, history will be tweaked, changed or have a torch put to it, anyway.
So the notion that screenwriters would get a little creative with the source material doesn't bother me, if the end result is a good movie.
Tim Burton was right: "A square jaw does not a Batman make." Steve Buscemi as the next Batman! Luke Perry as Joker! Let's make it happen!
My thinking is that if the life span of a comic title/individual character/group of characters gets past a certain point, history will be tweaked, changed or have a torch put to it, anyway.
So the notion that screenwriters would get a little creative with the source material doesn't bother me, if the end result is a good movie.
Haven, please ignore the above statement in relation to LotR. We don't want to start that again.
So here's a question: Why do the previews need to be 'determined' months in advance?
Because that's when work is being done on any particular set? It's easiest to look at the set then and think on what would make good previews rather than go back, you know? After all, it's not as if the figures or the set is going to change or anything in the spn of time between list generation and preview.
"Need" is such a strong word. The timing is more a matter of convenience.
That isn't to say there isn't flexibility, and I do exercise it, it's just easier this way.
Quote : Originally Posted by sol
it's easy to imagine what the previews would be like if they just said 'Jerome...go nuts"
I have never heard the word "No" when working on a preview schedule.
Quote : Originally Posted by wintremute
I really, really, really wish there was a real-life situation where I could tell a large group of people, "YOU ARE NO LONGER ALLOWED TO SPEAK THE WORDS TO LIONEL RICHIE'S SONG, HELLO, AS YOU ARE INTIMIDATING PEOPLE."
My thinking is that if the life span of a comic title/individual character/group of characters gets past a certain point, history will be tweaked, changed or have a torch put to it, anyway.
So the notion that screenwriters would get a little creative with the source material doesn't bother me, if the end result is a good movie.
I'm right with you on that.
For any of these films, as much as I may want a direct transfer from comics to screen in some cases, I only ask that the better of two choices be what makes it to the screen. Don't change something from the source material unless it's going to be an improvement either unto itself or because of other things that will depend on that decision. The aim is to be entertaining and internally consistent.
Such problems as I had with X-Men: First Class weren't crippling (no Xavier pun), but were noted. Several of the characters were there more as plot elements/mechanics than as characters, Sebastian Shaw's powers were altered so as to make them akin to magic (they could do whatever they wanted with them), none of the female characters (aside perhaps from Moira) were engaging, and some of the comedic training elements (Banshee's flight training in particular) fell flat for me.
On the other hand, the film moved at a brisk pace that belied its 131 minutes and it effectively created a foundation for a new run at the franchise that I'm more hopeful about than I was at any point in the original run of films.
Because that's when work is being done on any particular set? It's easiest to look at the set then and think on what would make good previews rather than go back, you know? After all, it's not as if the figures or the set is going to change or anything in the spn of time between list generation and preview.
"Need" is such a strong word. The timing is more a matter of convenience.
That isn't to say there isn't flexibility, and I do exercise it, it's just easier this way.
I have never heard the word "No" when working on a preview schedule.
Some people will give a lot more than compliments for that!
Quote : Originally Posted by Thrumble Funk
I think it is due to the fact that when you disagree with someone, you tend to lay into them in a way that, while more passive than aggressive, is still aggressive.
There is a level of passive-aggressiveness. Being from the Midwest, I've seen it a time or two. With that said, I've gotten to the point where I just avoid reading too much into any post. You just can't get the accurate tone someone is trying to convey most of the time on a message board on here. You could say something that is completely lighthearted, but someone might interpret the comment as being condescending or insulting (as what usually happens in GD). I think this is what rubs people the wrong way sometimes. You may be a seemingly lighthearted and positive individual, but some people will read a different tone into your posts. Typically this is done in an attempt at trolling.
I think the reason the Ogre threads work so well is we all understand that things being said in here are typically lighthearted. If there is something serious that needs to be said, it's pretty clear. We then move on to dirty jokes, youtube, and general fun. You can post a comment in here and know that nobody will take offense (99% of the time) because the original comment is known to be a jest.
Haven, please ignore the above statement in relation to LotR. We don't want to start that again.
No, if soxolas had been thinking of the LotR source material and movies it would have gone more like this:
Quote
So the notion that screenwriters would get a little creative with the source material, especially if that source material is tedious and dull, doesn't bother me, if the end result is a good movie.