Reaching here, my dude. I mean, it's a possibility, but it's a bit far fetched... especially when we have someone admitting to attempting a kill every night...

Why do you not think IR is the SK? Is it because he's telling you he isn't? Because that's what the SK would do.

So the SK failed. The mafia succeeded. Yet there are still two kills. I am not sure what point you are trying to make here.

Nifty made the other kill... as he stated... AND as I called.

My point is that there is/was another killer that was not town friendly. And I was correct. Why are you telling people not to listen to me? Everything I said so far has been accurate.

Because there was no evidence of a third kill before last night. Last night there was CLEARLY a blocked kill (Nyx stopping something). No kills were blocked (I should know) before that, or they weren't talked about. You happened to guess that there was potentially someone else with a kill power. Congrats. I could've called that.

You're trying to implant thoughts into the town: for instance that the other kill is unfriendly to town, which is unknowable at worst, at best we know it's not true if Nifty is telling the truth (which I happen to believe Nifty over, oh, the dead mafia member). He said he killed JoH with his one shot. I believe that more than I believe you and your phantom third killer.

You're trying to spin the town against me by attempting to sow doubt in what I'm saying. I hope they all realize this.

...I can't believe I'm arguing with the ghost of a mafia don...

Getting caught up. I failed last night.

I said yesterday that the mafia Night 1 and Night 2 kills were blocked. I wasn't guessing about another kill power.

I am not disagreeing with your assessment of things. Just pointing out that I was being truthful about the other killer.

Also, I think it is amazing that you let an SK stay alive this long. With how successful he has been, you know he is going to start targetting town.

I mean, I'd like to believe you, but I don't.

Who do you suspect is the other killer?

He could be. I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt, but his kill pattern alone isn't all that neutral. Normally wouldn't a serial killer try to balance the odds a little more?
Who was your target?

Our info gatherer was killed Night 2 so I have no idea. Maybe Gfish? Has anyone been able to verify his results?

I'll admit I am a little biased since he falls into the "players I never fully trust" category.

He might have been trying to do just that when he killed Cbob, someone who most had as town. Or he was trying to build the defense he's still using: he's the vig.

Gfish's on/off role play (I assume he canned that since it would be a pain from mobile) had me tripped up as well. So far I think his only "verified" claim was his drag of JoH. His other drag failed and I can't remember what happened to his other drag.

I still tend to believe him as town though.

Fair point. He could be building his claim at being town. However, looking back, I don't think he had a true reason to claim killer. If he is dirt, he's ballsy dirt.