Okay. You're asking the wrong questions here. It is not, "Is CurBludgeon's explanation satisfactory for me to do it his way"?

The question is: am I permitted to have PC carried out in this way?

The answer is: yes, as stated in the HCFL rules, with certain restrictions. These restrictions are based on whether I'm endangering the game from finishing on time.

Since we're on Turn 9 and have plenty of time left, that's not the problem.

Second question: Is my way an accepted way of doing it in the league?
Answer: yes. See precedents established in prior games throughout the league.

So here's my question to you: Under what right do you have to continue refusing to do so, especially considering a commissioner has already stepped in to say that my PC instructions exist for a valid reason?

Oh, and one more thing. You're asking me to commit to PC before I've seen the roll, so it wouldn't do me any good to check the link anyway, because it doesn't exist yet.

If you want to send the roll through HCUtils, under the condition that you confirm that to be your official move at the time the roll is made, then fine, send me the roll, with the relevant perplex listed, and I'll tell you at that point whether I choose to PC or not.

Well considering, I've used HCutil strictly you should not have to worry about the honest factor. Plus you are turning one simple PC into something complex. I just dont understand that.

You're ignoring my questions.

1) Under what right do you have to continue refusing to do so, especially considering a commissioner has already stepped in to say that my PC instructions exist for a valid reason?

2) Are you going to send me a roll with positions of moves to date?

Ok, this is getting a wee bit out of hand.

GA, just do your turn with the guide lines that Cur set. Sure, it's a bit meticulous, but that's part of this game and forum. We work with each other, and that's it. The second you guys start getting into each other, is the second you guys went too far before seeking a judges approval. Let's just drop it, and move on. It's only 6 more turns max. I'm sure once the turn is done to Cur's specifications (the far extreme of specifications, but still within a acceptable limit), the issue can be dropped. K?

Player 2, turn

Reed will leap over to F24 and perplex up Crystal's damage to 3
Crystal attacks, 7av+roll (4,2)=13 misses, pushing

F4 members have 18 def
---------------------------
Justice League of America (Satellite Era) (home)

1) E Green Arrow* 70 pts (6/7) N13@
* Trick Shot 20 pts
[5 SA, 3 KO]
2) E Batman* (IO) 47 pts (6/6) L14
* Dissent 18 pts
[1 SA, 1 AST, 1 DFD]
3) R Harbinger 50 pts (0/6) KOed
[1 AST]
4) R Saturn Girl 44 pts (4/4) O16
[3 AST]
5) R Red Tornado 42 pts (5/6) O11@
[1 AST]
6) R Aquaman* (HT) 27 pts (0/6) KOKO
* Contingency Plan 12 pts
[1 SA, 2 AST]
7) E Howard the Duck 35 pts (0/5) KOKO (Critical)
8) E Black Cat 32 pts (4/5) N12
[1 AST]

Total - 397 pts

vs

Fantastic Four (visitor)

A) V Thing* (SI) 100 pts (0/9) KOed SA: 1 - Injury incurred
2) V Human Torch* (CT) 73 pts (6/7) G14 SA:3, KO:2 RS OWed
3) R Ult Mr. Fantastic (FF) 47 pts (6/6) D24@ AST: 1
4) R Black Panther 27 pts (3/5) D22
5) R Invisible Girl* 37 pts (5/5) H8
6) U Crystal* 62 pts (2/7) P17@@ SA:1 -AV plx -1
7) E Silver Sable 43 pts (0/6) KOed - Injury incurred
8) Wyatt Wingfoot 6 pts (0/1) KOed
*ATA Fantastic Four

Total – 395 pts

HO: Aquaman, H8, K14
LO: I9, D17, N12

Map: Space

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...16y0&u8=x-28y2

BFC: Telekinetic Strain

When Telekinesis is used to move a character or object 6 or more squares, the character using Telekinesis is dealt 1 unavoidable damage after the movement is resolved

JLA (Sat) 10A:

(JLA) Saturn Girl attempts to break away: 5. She moves to N14.

(free) Batman outwits Johnny Storm's Running Shot, gaining a DFD.

(free) Saturn Girl perplexes Batman's range to 7.

1. Batman attacks Crystal. 10 on 18 for 2. 5+1 = 6. Black Cat PCs that to a 5, still missing.

---------------------------
Justice League of America (Satellite Era) (home)

1) E Green Arrow* 70 pts (6/7) N13
* Trick Shot 20 pts
[5 SA, 3 KO]
2) E Batman* (IO) 47 pts (6/6) L14@
* Dissent 18 pts
[1 SA, 1 AST, 2 DFD]
3) R Harbinger 50 pts (0/6) KOed
[1 AST]
4) R Saturn Girl 44 pts (4/4) N14@
[3 AST]
5) R Red Tornado 42 pts (5/6) O11
[1 AST]
6) R Aquaman* (HT) 27 pts (0/6) KOKO
* Contingency Plan 12 pts
[1 SA, 2 AST]
7) E Howard the Duck 35 pts (0/5) KOKO (Critical)
8) E Black Cat 32 pts (4/5) N12
[1 AST]

Total - 397 pts

vs

Fantastic Four (visitor)

A) V Thing* (SI) 100 pts (0/9) KOed SA: 1 - Injury incurred
2) V Human Torch* (CT) 73 pts (6/7) G14 SA:3, KO:2 RS OWed
3) R Ult Mr. Fantastic (FF) 47 pts (6/6) D24@ AST: 1
4) R Black Panther 27 pts (3/5) D22
5) R Invisible Girl* 37 pts (5/5) H8
6) U Crystal* 62 pts (2/7) P17@@ SA:1 -AV plx -1
7) E Silver Sable 43 pts (0/6) KOed - Injury incurred
8) Wyatt Wingfoot 6 pts (0/1) KOed
*ATA Fantastic Four

Total – 395 pts

HO: H8, K14
LO: I9, D17, N12

Map: Space

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...16y0&u8=x-28y2

BFC: Telekinetic Strain

When Telekinesis is used to move a character or object 6 or more squares, the character using Telekinesis is dealt 1 unavoidable damage after the movement is resolved

Player 2, turn 10

Reed will perplex down Batman's range to 5
Human torch will move to H-20
Black panther will move to I-21

F4 members ave 18def
------------------------------
Justice League of America (Satellite Era) (home)

1) E Green Arrow* 70 pts (6/7) N13
* Trick Shot 20 pts
[5 SA, 3 KO]
2) E Batman* (IO) 47 pts (6/6) L14@
* Dissent 18 pts
[1 SA, 1 AST, 2 DFD]
3) R Harbinger 50 pts (0/6) KOed
[1 AST]
4) R Saturn Girl 44 pts (4/4) N14@
[3 AST]
5) R Red Tornado 42 pts (5/6) O11
[1 AST]
6) R Aquaman* (HT) 27 pts (0/6) KOKO
* Contingency Plan 12 pts
[1 SA, 2 AST]
7) E Howard the Duck 35 pts (0/5) KOKO (Critical)
8) E Black Cat 32 pts (4/5) N12
[1 AST]

Total - 397 pts

vs

Fantastic Four (visitor)

A) V Thing* (SI) 100 pts (0/9) KOed SA: 1 - Injury incurred
2) V Human Torch* (CT) 73 pts (6/7) H20@ SA:3, KO:2 RS OWed
3) R Ult Mr. Fantastic (FF) 47 pts (6/6) D24 AST: 1
4) R Black Panther 27 pts (3/5) I21@
5) R Invisible Girl* 37 pts (5/5) H8
6) U Crystal* 62 pts (2/7) P17 SA:1
7) E Silver Sable 43 pts (0/6) KOed - Injury incurred
8) Wyatt Wingfoot 6 pts (0/1) KOed
*ATA Fantastic Four

Total – 395 pts

HO: H8, K14
LO: I9, D17, N12

Map: Space

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...16y0&u8=x-28y2

BFC: Telekinetic Strain

When Telekinesis is used to move a character or object 6 or more squares, the character using Telekinesis is dealt 1 unavoidable damage after the movement is resolved

JLA (Sat) 11A:

(free) Saturn Girl perplexes GA's range to 11.

1. GA will use Trick Shot/Fusillade. Attack #1 is on Invisible Girl. 11 on 18 for 2. 6+4 = 10, hitting for 2. 1 SA to GA; 1 AST to SG. Highest defense among F4 members is now 15. Attack #2 is on Crystal. 11 on 15 for 2. 3+6 = 9 for the KO. 1 SA and 1 KO to GA.

(free) Batman outwits Johnny's RS, gaining a DFD.

2. Batman l/c to N11.

3. Saturn Girl to O12, pushing.

------------------------------
Justice League of America (Satellite Era) (home)

1) E Green Arrow* 70 pts (6/7) N13@
* Trick Shot 20 pts
[7 SA, 4 KO]
2) E Batman* (IO) 47 pts (6/6) N11@@
* Dissent 18 pts
[1 SA, 1 AST, 3 DFD]
3) R Harbinger 50 pts (0/6) KOed
[1 AST]
4) R Saturn Girl 44 pts (3/4) O12@@
[4 AST]
5) R Red Tornado 42 pts (5/6) O11
[1 AST]
6) R Aquaman* (HT) 27 pts (0/6) KOKO
* Contingency Plan 12 pts
[1 SA, 2 AST]
7) E Howard the Duck 35 pts (0/5) KOKO (Critical)
8) E Black Cat 32 pts (4/5) N12
[1 AST]

Total - 397 pts

vs

Fantastic Four (visitor)

A) V Thing* (SI) 100 pts (0/9) KOed SA: 1 - Injury incurred
2) V Human Torch* (CT) 73 pts (6/7) H20@ SA:3, KO:2 RS OWed
3) R Ult Mr. Fantastic (FF) 47 pts (6/6) D24 AST: 1
4) R Black Panther 27 pts (3/5) I21@
5) R Invisible Girl* 37 pts (3/5) H8
6) U Crystal* 62 pts (0/7) KOed SA:1
7) E Silver Sable 43 pts (0/6) KOed - Injury incurred
8) Wyatt Wingfoot 6 pts (0/1) KOed
*ATA Fantastic Four

Total – 395 pts

HO: H8, K14
LO: I9, D17, N12

Map: Space

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...16y0&u8=x-28y2

BFC: Telekinetic Strain

When Telekinesis is used to move a character or object 6 or more squares, the character using Telekinesis is dealt 1 unavoidable damage after the movement is resolved.

Player 2, turn 11
Sue will move to d-12

If you want set there, fine be me.

EDIT: nevermind. Totally forgot about the space terrain bonus. I'll make my move later tonight.

Guess not.

I forfeit.

Hmm? Didn't quite make out that you were offering to end the game there. Anyhow, changes in red.

CurBludgeon's Justice League of America (Satellite Era)

U Batman** (AA) 120 pts
SA [3] KO [0] AST [13] DFD [3]
E Elongated Man 58 pts
SA [9] KO [3] AST [9] DFD [3]
R Red Tornado@@ 42 pts
SA [8] KO [8] AST [11] DFD [0]
R Aquaman* (JL) 70 pts
SA [15] KO [7] AST [7] DFD [0]
R Harbinger 50 pts
SA [5] KO [1] AST [3] DFD [1]
LE The Atom@ 75 pts
SA [7] KO [3] AST [0] DFD [0]
R Icemaiden 33 pts
SA [0] KO [0] AST [1] DFD [0]
E Saturn Girl# (LOSH) 60 pts
SA [4] KO [3] AST [16] DFD [2]
E Green Arrow## (JL) 70 pts
SA [22] KO [8] AST [0] DFD [0]
R Batman (AA) 64 pts
SA [8] KO [4] AST [0] DFD [0]
R Easy Company Medic 9 pts
SA [0] KO [0] AST [0] DFD [0]
V Black Cat 36 pts
SA [2] KO [2] AST [11] DFD [2]
R Sentinel Trooper 20 pts
SA [1] KO [1] AST [6] DFD [0]
E Howard The Duck 35 pts
SA [2] KO [1] AST [13] DFD [0]
U Crimson Avenger 53 pts
SA [0] KO [0] AST [0] DFD [0]

Lunge 5 pts
* Contingency Plan 12 pts, Lucky Break 5 pts
** Protected 8 pts, Thwart 15 pts, Swingline 10 pts, Double-Time 5 pts, Dissent 18 pts
# Compel 15 pts
## Trick Shot 20 pts, Double Time 5 pts
@ Saboteur 20 pts
@@ Nanobots 10 pts

39 Recruitment Points
Upgrades used this season: 12/12

I believe the turning point was turn 8,... if you would have moved Black Panther to B16 and Crystal to P15 you could still have OWed Batman, and Green Arrow wouldn't be able to shoot anyone.

Map