What is the difference between a controlled misdirector and your role?

Why would killingjoke show up as a misdirector on a night that he was performing a kill?

Early Day 2. Two of the dead baddies are voting for Darkstone.

Here's the thing, I don't know the specifics about Afrcngy's power so I can't say 100%. But based off of his earlier post, he doesn't learn what a player does. He instead learns something about them.

Why don't you suspect me or afrcngy, darkstone?
i'll ask the same question to killingjoke.

Jackofhearts constructed this highly elaborate post while he was being lined up for a lynch. He's screaming at us all to vote for Darkstone. This could be a genuine attempt to get a townie lynched, or it could be an effort to save his skin by bussing his last teammate. If we had lynched a townie yesterday, we'd be at 2 vs 2 vs 1 today. I'm not sure if that would resolve as an automatic mafia win, but if not then it would not have been too difficult for jack and his teammate (killingjoke) to sway Quebbster to join them.

@killingjoke: Why have you not killed Quebbster yet? He's been outed as a Neutral role since Day 3 and you've had plenty of opportunities to fire a shot at him, but you never did. Why not?

Doubler is not a role given to mafia/ Afrcngy's results have been accurate.

I don't suspect you because the mafia worked way too hard to lynch you.

But more importantly, the inconsistencies in KJ's reporting take priority

Vote Count

killingjoke: Quebbs, Darkstone, Sloonei
Darkstone: Afrcngy, killingjoke

LHLV: killingjoke

Approximately 11 hours remaining.

Also, I'm getting on a plane in about an hour and will likely not be back on until it's time to close the thread.

The thing that's giving me most pause right now is that two of the mafia members (jackofhearts & adamical) went to some pretty great lengths to try to frame darkstone, while none of them (Roy included) made any frequent mentions of killingjoke at all.

Darkstone: What are the most clear/obvious examples of your night actions resolving in a way that the rest of us can clearly identify?

N5 is the most I've seen in terms of write ups

Quebbster, who did you attempt to target last night?

Why did you almost not kill IR, killingjoke? Would you have killed somebody else, or opted not to kill at all?

Afrcngy. Thus, I have no reason to suspect foul play.

I've had a busy afternoon and I have to leave for work in an hour. I've been digging through this thread with all of my free time today. These high pressure end-game lynches are always difficult decisions but I think I've reached a fairly strong conclusion that killingjoke is the last scum member.

His vig claim is not validated by any of the host write-ups or night results. Both of the kills he has taken credit for were the only kills on their respective nights. The "small figures" who appear in the write-up also don't appear to be connected with the act of killing. My current guess is that they're connected with Immortal_Raven somehow, as they appear to save the would-be victim in the Night 2 write-up (as the would-be kill is resolving), and then they appear to carry off Raven's corpse on Night 4 (after the kill has resolved).

In addition to this, none of the dead mafia team members put up any resistance to killingjoke's vig claim, or spent any significant amount of time acknowledging him at all. But each of them accepted the vig claim implicitly while focusing on other targets for their fake suspicions.
One of their favorite targets to gain up on, incidentally, was Darkstone. Jackofhearts and adamic both spent significant time trying to get him lynched. This has been the issue I've gone back and forth on the most. Bussing is entirely possible and fairly common in my experience (obviously I can't speak to how common it is on this website, but I assume it happens sometimes). But the way they both worked to apparently frame Darkstone does not appear to be a bus job. Adam conjured up his own suspicion against Darkstone based on night results (which was also dependent on the night actions of Roy and killingjoke), and Joh spent his final hours in this game trying to spin a case against Darkstone. Both of these cases, but especially adam's, look like sincere efforts to get a player lynched. Bussing is usually done opportunistically, but Adam and Roy (and presumably killingjoke) seem to have gone out of their way specifically to create a case against Darkstone at one point in this game.

In addition to all of this, I find that I simply believe Darkstone. There does not appear to be anything forced about any of the things he's said or any of the night actions he's shared with us. He's made some questionable targets, but he's always just kind of shrugged at us in a way that suggests "it is what it is". It does not seem like he is hiding anything, and I've not found anything in the thread that contradicts any of his claimed night actions, despite my best efforts.

So barring some sort of miracle, I think I will be leaving my vote on killingjoke.