Anyone tried to play X-wing -vs- Flight Path?

A Star Trek player watched us play X-wing Saturday and seemed to think the two would be compatible, we're going to try it out at some point.

Not really. The different costing of stats really, really throw things out of whack. Especially with the higher attack die that Trek stuff can have.

I think Wakandaman mixes the two..............it doesn't look like it would mesh well to me thought.

We've given thought to it, but just looking at the numbers, Trek ships tend to be cheaper for what you get and their attack numbers are through the roof. Can you imagine trying to hit a cloaked ship with 2 attack dice on an A-wing? X-Wing ships tend to have a higher agility but it's not enough for me to think it'll make much difference.

Well one thought you could do for it would be to take the "stats" and use that as a point base and figure out what the pilots would be as Captains.

I think you could do it, as long as you don't care at all about how balanced the game is. The ships are not really scaled to each other (and I'm not talking about miniature scale here). They use two completely different systems for determining points. From a mechanics perspective though, they are pretty close (again, as long as you don't care about balance).

Id just use a "size" modifier...

Single craft attacking larger ships get + attack dice and extra defense due to their smaller size. (or Trek ships attacking smaller craft get - attack and have less defense dice).

I'd also use Star Wars cloaking rules.